City Hall Watcher

City Hall Watcher

A new term, a new team — and a towering divide

City Hall Watcher #410: Guest contributor Isaac Berman on how density helped Chow win re-election, plus Alex Olson looks at how our election projection performed and a preview of a Council meeting

Matt Elliott's avatar
Matt Elliott
Nov 16, 2026
∙ Paid

It’s the dawn of a new term. At the stroke of midnight last Saturday night, City Hall said goodbye to the last four years and hello to the next four. The official Council roster on the City’s website has been updated. It’s a brave new world.

Still, there’s good reason to think about how exactly we got here, so I’ve brought some special guests.

Isaac Berman, who you might know from his very helpful Observing the City website and social media accounts, makes his City Hall Watcher debut with a detailed look at how Mayor Olivia Chow saw an electoral benefit due to the strong support of people who live in high-rise towers — and how the move to build more dense developments around transit stations might help progressive politicians in coming elections.

After that, Alex Olson, the architect of City Hall Watcher’s Election Projection, is back with a look at how the projection did. Not too shabby, I think.

Finally, I’ve got a look at the committees councillors said they were interested in. I also name Council’s biggest keener. See if you can guess.

✨ This is a jam-packed issue, so it runs a bit long. If it gets cut off in your email client, read it on the web.

— Matt Elliott

matt@cityhallwatcher.com / Archives / Subscribe


The towering divide: how density helped Olivia Chow win re-election

By Isaac Berman

When discussing political divisions at City Hall, much is often made of the downtown versus suburban divide. It is framed this way both in the Council chamber when debating motions, and outside of it by the media during election season while discussing potential winning coalitions. Councillors outside of Old Toronto wards often frame their constituents as having different needs and desires than those downtown. However true this may be, the constituents in “suburban” wards are not a monolith.

An analysis of the poll-by-poll results from the 2026 election shows instead that there was a stark divide between residents within wards outside the downtown core. This divergence may be a result of Toronto’s zoning policies, and could be set to only be exacerbated further in the future.

Fighting with the yellow belt

Much of the new development in Toronto outside of the core has been forced into specific “tower corridors,” due to restrictive zoning policies.

Map titled “Toronto’s yellow belt” showing land zoned for low-rise residential use (R, RD, RS, RT and RM zones) in yellow. Yellow covers most residential land across the whole city, both inside and outside the outlined Toronto and East York district, leaving apartment areas, employment land and parks in grey.
Map of population change by census tract, 2016 to 2021, with subway and LRT lines and the Toronto and East York boundary. Most low-rise tracts across the north of the city lost residents, shown in red. Tracts that gained 1,500 or more residents, in dark blue, cluster downtown near the waterfront, along the subway in north-central Toronto, and in south Etobicoke.

Looking at census tracts outside of Toronto and East York, between 2016 and 2021, the tracts that are mostly zoned for the yellow belt (low-rise residential) lost about 2,200 residents, while the rest of those tracts — the tower corridors — gained about 23,500.

As these towers become home to more people, often younger and more likely to be newcomers than the low-rise residential neighbourhoods around them, the desires of residents within those wards shift.

Chow’s tower tendency

Downtown, Mayor Olivia Chow’s support did not differ between the neighbourhoods and towers. Those living downtown, even in low-rise residential areas, are more likely to take transit, bicycle, support new housing projects and self-select for “progressive” ideals like funding services even if it means higher property taxes.

Bar chart, “Tower polls vs. neighbourhood polls”: Chow’s election-day margin over Bradford. In Toronto and East York, Chow won tower polls and neighbourhood polls alike by 36 points. In the rest of the city, she won tower polls by 10 points and lost neighbourhood polls to Bradford by 1.

Outside of Old Toronto & East York, the story was different. Chow and Brad Bradford were essentially tied. However, Chow won subdivisions that were under 0.05km2 in size by 10 points. For the sake of this article, let’s call these “tower polls.” Tower polls are polling sites that serve either an individual building or cluster of buildings. In fact, Chow performed better in tower polls than neighbourhood polls in every single suburban ward.

Dot chart, “Tower polls vs. neighbourhood polls, by ward”: Chow’s margin over Bradford in tower polls and in neighbourhood polls for each of the 17 wards outside Toronto and East York. Chow did better in the tower polls in every ward. The gap is largest in Scarborough North (48 points), Scarborough-Rouge Park (26) and Scarborough-Agincourt, Scarborough Southwest and Etobicoke Centre (23 each), and smallest in York Centre and Don Valley North (3 each). Bradford won the neighbourhood polls in several wards, most heavily in York Centre, Etobicoke Centre and Eglinton-Lawrence.

Why does this matter? During Chow’s first term, there were two items that were part of the City’s “Expanding Housing Options in Neighbourhoods” (EHON) initiatives that the mayor allowed to have carve-outs. When it came to approving sixplexes and neighbourhood retail, suburban councillors were able to hinge their support for the items on the zoning amendments not affecting their wards.

Outside of Old Toronto, 52% of zoned land is in the yellow belt. These are the neighbourhoods that the carve-outs are trying to “protect”. It also means the growth that could have gone there keeps getting pushed into the same few corridors.

Map of Ward 18, Willowdale, coloured by election-day margin in each poll, with tower polls shown as circles sized by votes. The tower polls along the Yonge Street subway mostly went to Chow, while the low-rise neighbourhoods on either side went to Bradford, by more than 25 points in the northwest and north.

Willowdale is a perfect example of this. The ward’s tower polls, mostly along Yonge, went to Chow by five points. Bradford won the side streets on either side of the corridor by seven.

Map of Ward 15, Don Valley West, coloured by election-day margin in each poll, with tower polls shown as circles sized by votes. Bradford won most of the ward by more than 25 points, including the large low-rise areas north of Eglinton. Chow’s strongest area is Thorncliffe Park in the southeast, which she won by more than 25 points. Polls along the Eglinton line also leaned to her, and Leaside was mixed.

A similar phenomenon played out in Don Valley West, where new development has been constrained to specific transit corridors and “tower neighbourhoods” like Thorncliffe Park.

This pattern can be seen citywide, and suburban councillors would be wise to consider it.

Map of election-day results by poll for the city outside Toronto and East York, with tower polls shown as circles sized by votes. Scarborough is mostly purple for Chow, and central North York and much of Etobicoke are green for Bradford, but many of the tower circles inside the green areas are purple.

Major transit station areas could become major voting bloc

When a suburban councillor asks to be left out of planning reforms to allow sixplexes or corner stores, they are speaking for the low-rise neighbourhoods. The data suggests people in the towers down the road are not necessarily on the same page. Even though tower polls are a small share of the vote, making up only about 12% of election-day ballots outside of downtown, they are where most of the new housing is going. That growth is also about to speed up. The City is planning for more density in “Major Transit Station Areas” (MTSA), the land area around subway and LRT stations. Over half of these stations are outside of the core.

Map, “Major Transit Station Areas in wards without sixplexes”: station areas outlined over election-day results by poll, with Toronto and East York and Scarborough North, which have sixplex permissions, greyed out. Most station areas are shaded for Chow even where the surrounding ward, faded, leans to Bradford. This is clearest along the Finch West, Eglinton and Sheppard lines and in Scarborough.

The polls inside those station areas already lean toward Chow. In the wards that were carved out of the EHON initiative on sixplexes, she won the polling divisions within MTSAs by 12 points, while losing the rest of the polling divisions to Bradford by three. In every outer ward with a station area, Chow did better inside it than in the rest of the ward, by 17 points on average.

Dot chart, “Inside Major Transit Station Areas vs. the rest of the ward”: Chow’s margin over Bradford inside and outside station areas in 13 wards without sixplex permissions. Chow did better inside the station area in every one. The gap ranges from 29 points in York Centre and 22 in Don Valley West down to 6 in Scarborough Centre. Wards 2, 24 and 25 have no polls inside a station area.

With further development occurring in this pattern, the path to victory for a local councillor will surely move with it. Councillors in these wards should not operate under the assumption that they will stay suburban with a constituent base that has suburban sensibilities forever.

Isaac Berman is the creator of Observing The City, a project aimed at bringing transparency to data that is often hidden in PDF-based reports uploaded as attachments to City Council motions, and instead making it interactive and easy to digest. He hopes to be able to shift narratives that are often shaped by small interest groups and instead democratize access to information. You can follow Observing the City on Bluesky, Twitter, and TikTok.

Election Projection: How did our model do?

By Alex Olson

Now that the election is over, we can look back on our modelling and see how we did. As a reminder, our model’s final projection was a two-thirds chance that Chow would win, and by an average margin of about seven points. In real life, Chow won 100% of the time (in one election) and by 13 points. So was our model any good? How do we tell, and how does it stand when we compare it against other approaches?

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Matt Elliott.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Matt Elliott · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.